Path parts definitions
Path parts definitions
We need understandable and agreed terminligny for path parts.
What is Path? (Location or Location+Filename)
What is Filename (Filename or FIlename+extension)
I can't understand this:
"full paths and filenames"?
btw,
I suggest to use this:
Copy Path (C:\Folder\filename.ext)
Copy as Path ("C:\Folder\filename.ext")
"Copy Path" ("C:\Folder\filename.ext")
Copy Location (C:\Folder)
"Copy Location" ("C:\Folder")
In my suggestion, there is no FullPath in terminology. Path is always FullPath.
I don't have an idea how to distinguish between:
Filename
Filename.ext
Is there a better way than:
Copy Filename
Copy Filename.ext
What is Path? (Location or Location+Filename)
What is Filename (Filename or FIlename+extension)
I can't understand this:
"full paths and filenames"?
btw,
I suggest to use this:
Copy Path (C:\Folder\filename.ext)
Copy as Path ("C:\Folder\filename.ext")
"Copy Path" ("C:\Folder\filename.ext")
Copy Location (C:\Folder)
"Copy Location" ("C:\Folder")
In my suggestion, there is no FullPath in terminology. Path is always FullPath.
I don't have an idea how to distinguish between:
Filename
Filename.ext
Is there a better way than:
Copy Filename
Copy Filename.ext
Re: Path parts definitions
("folder" or "directory" ?
[I wonder why "folder" even came about.]
I'm thinking, from time to time, there may be some slight confusion, but more often it is here in these forums when wanting to describe a particular situation where someone might say "file" or "path" or "pathname" thinking in their mind a particular meaning, where others read it differently, & less of an issue in the program UI & working, itself.)
[I wonder why "folder" even came about.]
I'm thinking, from time to time, there may be some slight confusion, but more often it is here in these forums when wanting to describe a particular situation where someone might say "file" or "path" or "pathname" thinking in their mind a particular meaning, where others read it differently, & less of an issue in the program UI & working, itself.)
Re: Path parts definitions
It is very hard to come up with a good and clear definition. Maybe even too hard (otherwise there would be a good naming standard by now, I guess)
To add to the confusion, my idea ( :-p)
Drive = C:
Path = \Program Files\Eveything\
Base name = Everything
Extension = .exe
Fully qualified filename: c:\program files\everything\everything.exe
(so C:\file.txt has a path: "\")
But that's still not clear enough:
- Should the extension be .exe or just exe?
- Modern Windows filesystems support more namespaces beyond the good old DOS one: \\?\C: ... (to support very long filenames (eh ...) ) \\?\UNC\.. \\.\ (to bypass the filesystem and talk on a device level to the files). And there is the good old \\server\share syntax
Should those all be called "drive" too?
P.S: I like "location"! Thats a good description.
To add to the confusion, my idea ( :-p)
Drive = C:
Path = \Program Files\Eveything\
Base name = Everything
Extension = .exe
Fully qualified filename: c:\program files\everything\everything.exe
(so C:\file.txt has a path: "\")
But that's still not clear enough:
- Should the extension be .exe or just exe?
- Modern Windows filesystems support more namespaces beyond the good old DOS one: \\?\C: ... (to support very long filenames (eh ...) ) \\?\UNC\.. \\.\ (to bypass the filesystem and talk on a device level to the files). And there is the good old \\server\share syntax
Should those all be called "drive" too?
P.S: I like "location"! Thats a good description.
Re: Path parts definitions
Currently, Everything uses "path" to describe the "path part" internally and in the UI.
The "Path" column should be changed to "Folder" to match Windows Explorer.
Windows Explorer also uses "Location" or "Folder Path" (See the file properties page).
"Full path and filename" should be "fully qualified file name" or just "path".
Everything uses "Name Part" or "Name Part Only" when the extension is not wanted (see namepartdupe:).
This is still not clear as "Name part" often includes the extension. Windows usually does not deal with the name part only.
The "Path" column should be changed to "Folder" to match Windows Explorer.
Windows Explorer also uses "Location" or "Folder Path" (See the file properties page).
"Full path and filename" should be "fully qualified file name" or just "path".
Everything uses "Name Part" or "Name Part Only" when the extension is not wanted (see namepartdupe:).
This is still not clear as "Name part" often includes the extension. Windows usually does not deal with the name part only.
Re: Path parts definitions
It's not clear what is the "path part".void wrote:Currently, Everything uses "path" to describe the "path part" internally and in the UI.
when you say Copy Path what will be the intention:
C:\Folder\filename.ext
or
C:\Folder
I think using the term Folder can lead to misunderstanding.The "Path" column should be changed to "Folder" to match Windows Explorer.
Windows Explorer also uses "Location" or "Folder Path" (See the file properties page).
C:\Folder\Folder
RightClick > Copy Folder
I would prefer:
RightClick > Copy Location
just "path" is ok, but we need to be consistent after the decision is taken."Full path and filename" should be "fully qualified file name" or just "path".
If people can be confused how to interpret Path, I'm ok with FullPath. (and not using Path at all)
Yes, I think we need to get more suggestions to find a definition that will distinguish betweenEverything uses "Name Part" or "Name Part Only" when the extension is not wanted (see namepartdupe:).
This is still not clear as "Name part" often includes the extension. Windows usually does not deal with the name part only.
Filename
and
Filename.ext
maybe:
Filename
and
File.name (with a dot)
Copy Filename
Copy File.name
Copy Filename
Copy FileN.ame
Copy Name
Copy N.ame
(mixture of folders and files)
or:
Copy Name
Copy FullName
Last edited by Stamimail on Wed Feb 28, 2018 10:28 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Path parts definitions
path part = the folder location.
C:\Folder for C:\Folder\filename.ext
"Folder Location" could also work.
C:\Folder for C:\Folder\filename.ext
I prefer location here too, put on my TODO list.I think using the term Folder can lead to misunderstanding.
C:\Folder\Folder
RightClick > Copy Folder
I would prefer:
RightClick > Copy Location
"Folder Location" could also work.
Re: Path parts definitions
I can say, that currently in my local Everything, I have:I prefer location here too, put on my TODO list.
"Folder Location" could also work.
|Location| (as column header, instead of Path)
RCMenu:
Open
Open Location
Copy Path to clipboard
Copy Location to clipboard
(Path in my Everything always means FullPath)
Re: Path parts definitions
File name part proposal for Everything 1.5:
For Example, if the file is: C:\Program Files\Everything\Everything.exe
Path on its own is vague, I would like to keep using full path and filename to clarify that it is the fully qualified path and filename.
For filename functions, pathpart and namepart should remain unchanged, I'll add parentpath (same function as pathpart) and change the documentation.
For Example, if the file is: C:\Program Files\Everything\Everything.exe
- Full Path and Filename: C:\Program Files\Everything\Everything.exe
Folder or Folder Location: C:\Program Files\Everything
Filename: Everything.exe
Name Part: Everything
Parent Path: C:\Program Files\Everything
Extension (always without dot): exe
Path on its own is vague, I would like to keep using full path and filename to clarify that it is the fully qualified path and filename.
For filename functions, pathpart and namepart should remain unchanged, I'll add parentpath (same function as pathpart) and change the documentation.
Re: Path parts definitions
Since the word "Path" has many meanings which can cause confusion,Path on its own is vague
Do you think it is possible not to use the word "Path" at all?
I think someone needs to take the world one step further.
Re: Path parts definitions
On its own, yes.Do you think it is possible not to use the word "Path" at all?
I would like to use it only when specifying full path and filename or fully qualified path and filename.
Re: Path parts definitions
Do you think it is possible not to use the word "Path" at all? To find terminology alternatives also to "full path and filename" or "fully qualified path' and filename"?void wrote:On its own, yes.Do you think it is possible not to use the word "Path" at all?
I would like to use it only when specifying full path and filename or fully qualified path and filename.